The Short Take
CustomStickers.com vs PrintPlace is a pretty clear specialist-versus-generalist comparison. PrintPlace has a real sticker catalog, especially for singles, roll stickers and bulk sticker printing. But CustomStickers.com is the better choice for most people who want durable custom stickers.
PrintPlace is useful if you need stickers as part of a broader commercial print order. CustomStickers.com is better if you care about sticker quality, value, proofing and getting the order right without feeling like you wandered into a printer’s back office.
We STRONGLY recommend CustomStickers over Print Place for stickers specifically.
The Scorecard
| Category | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Sticker Quality | CustomStickers.com | Stronger quality score and better vinyl sticker positioning |
| Price And Value | CustomStickers.com | Much better value in our sticker comparison set |
| Sticker Formats | PrintPlace | Good range of sticker singles, roll stickers and bulk options |
| Proofing And Support | CustomStickers.com | More sticker-specific proofing and customer support |
| Turnaround | Close | PrintPlace can be fast, but CustomStickers.com is stronger overall |
| Best Overall | CustomStickers.com | Better for most custom vinyl sticker orders |
PrintPlace has useful sticker products. CustomStickers.com is the better sticker company.
Where PrintPlace Makes Sense
PrintPlace is a multiproduct online printer. Stickers are one part of a much larger catalog. That can be convenient if you are already ordering other print products and want to keep everything with one vendor.
PrintPlace offers sticker singles, roll stickers, vinyl stickers and bulk stickers. Its site also provides layout templates in formats like EPS, PDF and JPG, which is helpful for designers working in Illustrator or Photoshop. For roll stickers, it supports standard shapes like rectangle, square, circle and oval, with custom shapes available.
That makes PrintPlace useful for packaging labels, product seals, promotional stickers and commercial print buyers who already know what they are doing.
But it is not the strongest option if your goal is simply to order premium custom stickers. That is where CustomStickers.com pulls ahead.
Where CustomStickers.com Wins
CustomStickers.com is built around stickers. It focuses on durable vinyl, waterproof materials, accurate cutting, free online proofs and free U.S. shipping.
That is a cleaner fit for most sticker buyers. You are not navigating a massive print catalog. You are choosing a sticker type, uploading artwork, reviewing a proof and getting the order produced.
In our internal sticker printer matrix, CustomStickers.com ranks first overall. PrintPlace sits near the bottom of the sticker set. That does not mean PrintPlace cannot print stickers. It means CustomStickers.com is much stronger when the comparison is specifically about custom sticker quality and value.
A general printer can be fine for a lot of things. But if the product you care about is stickers, use the sticker specialist.
Quality: The Main Difference
Quality is where this CustomStickers.com vs PrintPlace comparison becomes easy.
CustomStickers.com has a stronger quality score and a stronger vinyl sticker story. Its stickers are made for real use: laptops, water bottles, packaging, windows, helmets, events and brand giveaways. The company also emphasizes waterproof vinyl, UV-resistant laminate and accurate die cutting.
PrintPlace offers vinyl stickers and roll stickers, but its internal score is lower. Our notes describe PrintPlace as not a go-to choice for vinyl stickers, with quality complaints and inconsistent customer-service feedback showing up as concerns.
PrintPlace may work for basic business labels or lower-stakes promo stickers. CustomStickers.com is the better option when the sticker needs to look sharp, feel good and hold up over time.
Price And Value: CustomStickers.com By A Lot
PrintPlace can look practical on bulk commercial printing, especially if you are ordering non-vinyl products or larger print runs. But in our sticker-specific matrix, PrintPlace performs poorly on price.
CustomStickers.com has the stronger value position because it combines high-quality vinyl stickers with aggressive pricing, free online proofs and free shipping. That is the bundle that matters.
Sticker pricing should not be judged by the first number you see. You have to consider material quality, shipping, proofing, durability and whether you trust the final result. A cheaper-looking sticker is not cheaper if you have to reorder it somewhere else.
PrintPlace may make sense for certain commercial label jobs. For custom vinyl stickers, CustomStickers.com is the better value.
Design And File Setup
PrintPlace has decent file-prep resources. Its layout templates are useful for designers, especially people who are comfortable working with print specs. That makes PrintPlace feel more like a traditional commercial printer.
CustomStickers.com is more approachable for normal sticker buyers. Upload artwork, get a proof, approve or request changes, then print. The proofing flow is the real advantage.
If you are a print pro and want templates for exact file setup, PrintPlace can help. If you want a simpler sticker ordering process with a human proof checkpoint, CustomStickers.com is better.
Most buyers do not want to study layout templates unless they absolutely have to. They want the sticker to look right. Hard to blame them.
Customer Service And Proofing
CustomStickers.com wins on customer service in our scoring. Its proof-first workflow gives buyers a clear chance to catch issues before production. That matters for cutlines, small text, QR codes, complex shapes and low-resolution uploads.
PrintPlace has support resources, but our sticker-specific notes are more cautious. The concern is not that PrintPlace has no service. The concern is consistency, especially for vinyl sticker orders.
Custom stickers are too easy to mess up if the proofing process is weak. The difference between “great sticker” and “why is the cutline doing that?” can be tiny. CustomStickers.com gives buyers more confidence before production.
Turnaround And Shipping
PrintPlace can be fast when everything goes smoothly. Its sticker pages mention fast print turnaround on bulk stickers and multiple sticker formats. That is one of its stronger points.
CustomStickers.com also has quick, predictable turnaround and free shipping. More importantly, it pairs turnaround with stronger quality, pricing and support.
A fast order is nice. A fast order that also looks good is better. Groundbreaking stuff, I know.
For most buyers, CustomStickers.com is the safer speed-plus-quality choice.
Best Use Cases
Choose CustomStickers.com for:
- Custom vinyl stickers
- Die-cut logo stickers
- Waterproof stickers
- Laptop stickers
- Water bottle stickers
- Product packaging stickers
- Artist merch
- Event stickers
- Repeat business sticker orders
Choose PrintPlace for:
- Sticker orders bundled with broader commercial printing
- Roll stickers for packaging
- Bulk sticker jobs where PrintPlace specs fit your needs
- Designers who want layout templates
- Businesses already using PrintPlace for other print products
Pros And Cons
CustomStickers.com Pros
- Better overall sticker score
- Stronger quality and value
- Free online proofs
- Free U.S. shipping
- Waterproof vinyl options
- Better for durable custom stickers
- Cleaner sticker-focused ordering process
CustomStickers.com Cons
- Less of a broad commercial print platform
- Not built around downloadable layout templates as the main workflow
- Best for buyers who have artwork ready
PrintPlace Pros
- Offers sticker singles, rolls and bulk stickers
- Useful layout templates for designers
- Good for commercial print buyers
- Supports standard and custom sticker shapes
- Can be fast on some orders
PrintPlace Cons
- Much lower overall sticker score
- Weak value for vinyl stickers in our matrix
- Less sticker-specialist support
- Mixed quality and service concerns
- Better as a general printer than a custom sticker specialist
Final Verdict
PrintPlace is useful if you already live in the world of commercial print specs, layout templates and broader print orders. It has real sticker products and can work for certain label and packaging needs.
But CustomStickers.com is the better choice for custom stickers.
In this CustomStickers.com vs PrintPlace comparison, CustomStickers.com wins on quality, value, proofing and overall confidence. PrintPlace is a general printer with sticker options. CustomStickers.com is a sticker specialist.